Tom's Mom's Cookies has been an absolute institution in Harbor Springs, Michigan since the summer of 1985. They still make their award-winning cookies the same way they did that summer: weighing, cutting, and cooking everything by hand. In a world with a lot of great cookies these are a game changer.

Show up at your next Holiday party, book club, or gift exchange with this deliciousness from Trader Joe's, and you'll be asked back immediately. Sweet cinnamon with horchata flavored cookies blended in for unmistakeable texture, this one is a winner.